
The Philippines aimed to secure a code of conduct with China during its 2026 ASEAN presidency to manage tensions in the South China Sea, but a breakthrough proved elusive.
By the November 2026 ASEAN summit in Manila, nearly 80% of the text had been negotiated, according to Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro, yet fundamental disputes, including the code’s legal binding nature and geographic scope, remained unresolved.
Key Obstacles in Negotiations
The South China Sea is a vital global shipping route, abundant in fishing grounds and possible energy reserves. China claims much of the area via its ‘Nine-Dash Line,’ overlapping notably with claims from the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, and Brunei.
Disagreement persists on whether the code of conduct should be a legally binding treaty or a non-binding set of guidelines. Political scientists and experts point out China’s reluctance to accept binding restrictions, as it currently maintains strategic freedom without formal agreements.
One major geographic dispute involves the Paracel Islands, claimed by both China and Vietnam. Vietnam wants these included within the code’s jurisdiction, while China rejects this inclusion, fearing it would affect territorial claims.
Divergent Interests Within ASEAN and China’s Strategy
ASEAN’s 11 member states are divided, with the Philippines and Vietnam generally opposing China more vocally, while Malaysia and Indonesia adopt a measured stance. Cambodia and Laos, with close Chinese ties and no territorial claims in the sea, further complicate consensus building.
China appears to prefer maintaining a state of controlled tension without committing to binding rules, strengthening its position without ceding influence, according to experts from the German Institute of Global and Area Studies and the German Institute for International and Security Affairs.
Furthermore, ASEAN’s consensus-based decision-making allows any member to block unified agreements, hindering collective progress.
Limitations and Future Prospects
Even if a code is finalized, experts caution it will not resolve territorial disputes but may assist in managing maritime incidents. Contentious issues like a clear definition of incidents—from coast guard actions to blockades—still require resolution to ensure effectiveness.
The American Center for Strategic and International Studies concluded that despite progress during the 2026 summit, the toughest issues remain unsettled. Negotiations will resume in 2027 under Singapore’s leadership.
The success of future talks depends on whether China will consent to regulations that limit its actions and whether ASEAN can bridge internal divisions to present a unified front.






