United Nations negotiations focused on regulating lethal autonomous weapons systems, often referred to as “killer robots,” concluded on Saturday without reaching an agreement on a legally binding ban. Delegates representing 128 states, all parties to the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW), gathered in Geneva throughout the week to address rising global concerns with these autonomous systems capable of independently selecting and engaging targets. Despite calls from nearly 100 nations, as well as endorsements from prominent figures like UN Secretary-General António Guterres and Pope Leo XIV, no consensus was achieved to prohibit these weapons outright.

However, the conference did end with an agreement to continue discussions and work towards developing new international rules on lethal autonomous weapons over the next two years, aiming for a framework to be in place by 2028. This compromise was viewed as insufficient by advocacy groups but represents a step forward in diplomatic efforts amid sharply divided national positions.

Contentious Negotiations Reflect Divergent National Positions

The debate centered on the core issue of whether to establish a clear, legally binding prohibition on autonomous weapons systems that can kill without human intervention. While a majority of nations favored restrictions or outright bans, several major arms-producing countries, including the United States, Russia, and Israel, opposed a binding mandate. These countries hold significant technological capabilities and resisted limiting development through definitive international law.

In the final declaration, the 128 participating countries agreed to initiate the creation of an international instrument regulating lethal autonomous weapons. The Swiss chair of the conference, Julien Thoni, described the outcome as “concrete results” achieved despite deep global divisions, emphasizing the ongoing multilateral dialogue. He announced that elaboration of the instrument will continue over two years to establish clearer rules.

Rights Groups Criticize the Outcome as Diluted and Uncertain

Human rights and advocacy organizations expressed disappointment with the weakened mandate that emerged from the talks. The international coalition Stop Killer Robots, representing over 300 groups, criticized the final agreement for failing to map a definitive path toward a legally binding treaty. The coalition noted that while more than 95 states supported a treaty, a small number of countries diluted the agreement at the last moment, casting doubt on the legal clarity and status of the resulting instrument.

The coalition highlighted that lethal autonomous weapons systems are already emerging on battlefields, referring specifically to their deployment and testing in contexts such as the conflict in Ukraine. The ongoing use of such technologies increases concerns about accountability and ethical implications, underscoring the coalition’s call for stronger international restrictions.